Home › CFA® Level II › Corporate Finance
CFA® Level II · Corporate Finance · free lesson
Analysis of Dividends and Share Repurchases
How a company returns cash to its owners affects their taxes, the signals the market reads, the incentives of managers and the ratios analysts track. This module explains the forms of dividends and repurchases, the main theories of payout policy, the effect of different tax systems, and how to measure a buyback's effect on EPS and book value and judge whether a dividend is safe. Level II vignettes typically combine several of these calculations with a judgement about a proposed payout decision.
What you will learn
1. Analyse how cash dividends, stock dividends, stock splits and liquidating payouts affect shareholder wealth and financial ratios.
- A cash dividend lowers the share price by about the dividend on the ex-date; without taxes, holder wealth is unchanged.
- Cash dividends reduce cash and equity: liquidity ratios fall and leverage ratios rise.
- Stock dividends and splits change the share count and price per share but not total value, ownership stakes or total-based ratios.
- US GAAP records a small stock dividend at market value and a large one at par; IFRS has no specific rule, and total equity never changes.
- A liquidating dividend is a return of capital, not a distribution of earnings.
2. Compare the main theories of dividend policy, the signalling effect of payout changes and agency-cost explanations of payout policy.
- MM irrelevance needs perfect markets; investors can then create homemade dividends.
- Bird-in-the-hand says dividends lower the required return; the tax argument favours low payouts where dividends are taxed more than gains.
- Dividends are smoothed, so increases and initiations signal confidence and cuts signal trouble.
- Payouts reduce the agency cost of free cash flow but can transfer value from bondholders, hence dividend covenants.
- Practical drivers: investment opportunities, earnings volatility, flexibility, taxes, flotation costs and legal restrictions.
3. Calculate the effective tax rate on distributed earnings under double-taxation, split-rate and imputation systems, and calculate dividends under stable, constant payout ratio and residual policies.
- Double taxation: ETR = t_c + (1 - t_c)t_i.
- Split-rate: use the corporate rate on distributed earnings in the same formula.
- Imputation: the total tax on distributed earnings equals the shareholder's marginal rate.
- Target payout adjustment: D1 = D0 + (target payout x E1 - D0) x adjustment factor.
- Residual dividend = earnings minus the equity-financed part of the capital budget (zero if negative).
4. Calculate the effect of a share repurchase on EPS and book value per share when funded with cash or debt, and compare repurchases with cash dividends.
- EPS after buyback = (earnings - after-tax cost of funds) / (shares - amount / price).
- EPS rises only if the earnings yield exceeds the after-tax cost of the funds used.
- BVPS falls when the repurchase price exceeds BVPS and rises when it is below.
- Without taxes, a buyback and an equal cash dividend leave shareholders equally wealthy.
- Buybacks are flexible, can signal undervaluation and offset dilution, and are often tax-advantaged.
5. Assess the safety of a company's dividend using earnings-based and cash-flow-based coverage ratios and other warning signs.
- Dividend coverage = net income / dividends; payout ratio = dividends / net income.
- FCFE coverage = FCFE / (dividends + repurchases); below 1 means distributions exceed the cash available.
- Earnings-based coverage ignores investment needs; FCFE-based coverage includes buybacks and capital spending.
- Warning signs: high payout versus history and peers, very high yield, falling coverage, rising leverage.
- Judge payout levels against sector norms; utilities and REITs pay out most earnings by design.
Module at a glance
- Cash dividends reduce cash and equity, so liquidity ratios fall and leverage ratios rise; stock dividends and splits change only the share count and price per share.
- MM irrelevance needs perfect markets; bird-in-the-hand, tax, clientele, signalling and agency arguments explain why payout policy matters in practice.
- Effective tax on distributed earnings: t_c + (1 - t_c)t_i under double taxation, the distributed-earnings rate under split-rate, and the shareholder's rate under imputation.
- Lintner's model: next dividend = last dividend + adjustment factor x (target payout x expected earnings - last dividend).
- A buyback raises EPS only when the earnings yield exceeds the after-tax cost of funds, and lowers BVPS when the price exceeds book value per share.
- Without taxes, a buyback and an equal dividend leave shareholders equally wealthy; buybacks add flexibility and are often tax-efficient.
- FCFE coverage = FCFE / (dividends + buybacks) is a stricter safety test than earnings coverage.
This free module has 5 lessons, 14 practice questions with full explanations.